When I read the recent post by Dr. Micheal Klein in the Sense and Sensibility blog telling us that both OBs under the age of 40 and pregnant moms are fearful of childbirth today, and that this is deeply worrying if we want to have a women-centered model of giving birth, I had a flash back:
It was 2004, I lived in Takoma Park, Maryland, and had just learned that Dr. Marsden Wagner, former director of Women’s and Children’s Health in the World Health Organization for 15 years, lived three blocks from my house. Since I was writing a play on childbirth I thought it would be useful to speak to him so I called him up. He said come on over. He was finishing up the manuscript for his book "Born in the USA: How a Broken Maternity Care System Must Be Fixed To Put Women and Children First " when I walked in holding my notepad. Within a minute I began scribbling furiously...the passion and urgency in his voice was palpable.
Why don't pregnant moms make better birth choices?, I asked.
They are being sold fear by the medical establishment, he said.
Why are they buying it?
Because power is sexy, he explained, and OBs have power.
How is this going to change?
Two things: First, the education of OBs must change. If all they get taught is fear that's all they will have to offer. Second, pregnant mothers have to change. Ultimately, they are the power brokers.
How do pregnant mothers have to change?
They have to say no, he said.
No?
Yes, no...no to a medical system that puts them last on the list, no to the lack of true midwifery options, no to the way they are spoken to at prenatal visits...or not spoken to and not given accurate information.
What do you think will change childbirth today?
A revolution led by mothers. It's the only way forward, he said.
At the time as a playwright interviewing my subject I thought Dr. Wagner was eccentric, and he is. But as a mother, birth activist and life-long community organizer I also knew he was right: revolution is the only way forward.
It was hard back then to find an OB who would echo Dr. Wagner's sentiment. Revolution was just too radical a term in 2004. Wasn't there a more polite way to call for social change? Well, today Dr. Wagner has a few obstetric friends in Camp Revolution. Dr. Klein is one of them.
rev·o·lu·tion/ˌrevəˈlo͞oSHən/Noun
1. A forcible overthrow of a government or social order for a new system.
Dr. Klein's recent blog post got me thinking again about the wisdom of this idea. How can we improve childbirth choices for pregnant mothers and start teaching pregnant moms and new OBs to trust childbirth, not fear it? How can we overthrow a maternity care order for a new system?
Revolution.
I think there are a few mini-childbirth revolutions happening in some communities - mothers are standing up for their childbirth rights (thank you Joy Szabo). And even attempts on a global stage (the Women Deliver conference, but having attended it last June I was let down by the 'show' of it).
Ultimately the community organizer in me knows that sustainable change has to come from a revolution by the grassroots - from the pregnant mothers themselves - a trickle up process - who must stand up and say they are fed up with childbirth models that for the most part don't work for pregnant moms.
If we want social change revolution is the answer.
My revolution looks like this: let's teach freedom instead of fear to pregnant moms and their partners today, and to the pregnant women and men of tomorrow, and to a new generation of OBs. Let's examine social change movements around the world, find the ones that work, and use these models to build a women-centered childbirth model that works.
Revolution up!
5 comments:
I love the teaching freedom idea! That's the clarity needed to change the current fear based paradigm that infuses birth. Marsden Wagner is spot on. Power is seductive and obstetricians wield their power like a scythe....oooops, scalpel
Yes, teach freedom. Education is the path of freedom.
I just wanted to add that the beautiful bell hooks wrote a fabulous book about education for liberation called "Teaching to Transgress" an excellent read and even manifesto for our (birthing)times. (and bell hooks always spells her name with lower case first letters). This book certainly deeply influenced my understanding, philosophy and teaching style as well as my midwifery work.
Thanks so much for the bell hooks reference! I love her work, but haven't read her in a while and will be sure to read "Teaching to Trangress"!
I didn't mention it in my blog post, but this Fall my FEAR to FREEDOM Birth Training certification program launches. The pre-launch class is in full-swing now - there is actually one woman from Australia in it and several other countries outside the US. The whole idea is to move pregnant moms from FEAR to FREEDOM in their birth. We're starting to train people in this method to use with pregnant moms, and hoping to adapt it to use with other communities (like the medical community). Fear to Freedom! xo
This is an amazing article and just in the "nick of time" for me personally. I have an appeal hearing tomorrow with my insurance carrier who has refused to cover my birth center birth even though my midwifes are contracted. I have been fighting hard to change their policy and allow other women to have a choice. I have started a petition at change.org and am using this along with letters from my midwifes, the birth center's director of operations, and numerous articles and studies. This article gave me hope that I am not the only one fighting for a revolution. ( http://www.change.org/petitions/tell-geisinger-choice-to-support-birth-center-births?utm_medium=facebook&utm_source=share_petition&utm_term=own_wall#signatures )
Good luck, Holly! Revolution up!
Post a Comment